Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Amanda B. Hinton's avatar

Noha, I've been simmering on this piece (as I am wont to do) for a few days because I've been trying to put shape to what it planted in my mind. The rhythmic nature of the writing is, yes, beautiful — and I can't help but notice the parallels to something I experienced when I began exploring more historically grounded Christian traditions in my 20s. A bit of context: I grew up in what would be considered an offshoot, independent and very unstructured Christian church. Imagine pentecostal but more subdued; it had a loosely defined statement of faith but nothing rigid; it was a ripe playground for financial mishappenings because no one but the pastor saw the books. While I can understand why many people in the 80s and 90s (my parents among them) were drawn to a religious experience that had none of the ritualistic trappings (like structured days of fasting, repentance, daily and weekly prayers), I do think something was missing from the rhythms of our family life because it was so wide open and unstructured. In fact, I've had many religious friends in my life convert to Catholicism or Orthodox Christianity and talk about the "breath of fresh air" and the "weight lifted off their shoulders" — much of which I think is owed to the structure of religious life being reliable and creating a sense of communal, connective prayer.

In the context of your piece here (thank you for sticking with me!), I felt a certain resonance around the visual invitation to pause for prayer five times a day and to sink into the rhythms of life and also the rhythms of the intentional, heartfelt spoken word that prayer becomes. It helped me feel a sort of connection with you and to also wonder: what is prayer but a knocking on an invisible door? How often do we go through life and feel drawn to the invisible and unseen and long for a way to step even an inch closer? That invitation to knock intentionally really feels so full of potential to me, even as I'm not religiously affiliated anymore. I do feel as though when you and I pray we are knocking on that same invisible door. And it's just nice to know I'm in such good company.

Expand full comment
Joyce Wycoff's avatar

@Noha Beshir ... what a beautiful explanation of prayer. I am neither Muslim nor Christian nor Jew. but feel a deep yearning for the connection that comes from the practice of prayer from an early age.

Read.

Such a simple command.

Poetry and prayer.

The elegance and gentleness of your words will stay with me.

Expand full comment
64 more comments...

No posts